c++11,visual-studio-2013,language-lawyer,msvc12 , MSVC 12 std::initializer_list bug when copying std::string

MSVC 12 std::initializer_list bug when copying std::string


Tag: c++11,visual-studio-2013,language-lawyer,msvc12

I'm trying to create a C++ program with MSVC 12 (Visual Studio 2013, Update 4) which uses a std::initializer_list of structs which have std::string members. I seem to have run into a bug in MSVC. Here's a minimal example which exhibits the problem:

#include <cassert>
#include <initializer_list>
#include <string>

    struct TestStructure
        std::string m_string;
        int m_integer;

        TestStructure(const std::string& string, int integer)
            : m_string(string), m_integer(integer)

        TestStructure(const TestStructure&) = default;
        ~TestStructure() = default;
        TestStructure& operator=(const TestStructure&) = default;

int main(int, char **)
    TestStructure structure("foobar", 12345);
    std::initializer_list<TestStructure> structures({structure});

    assert(structure.m_integer == 12345);
    assert(structure.m_string == "foobar");
    assert(structures.size() == 1);
    assert(structures.begin()->m_integer == 12345);
    assert(structures.begin()->m_string == "foobar"); // abort()'s here.

    return EXIT_SUCCESS;

I would expect that this program would compile and execute without any problems. However, when I run it the last assertion seems to fail. Looking in the Visual Studio debugger, it would seem that structures.begin()->m_string == "".

Is my program somehow not well-formed, or is this actually a bug in MSVC? Is there some workaround for this problem (other than just not using initializer lists)?


The problem is that you're using both parentheses and braces:

std::initializer_list<TestStructure> structures({structure});
                                               ^^         ^^

This will construct a temporary std::initializer_list<TestStructure> and copy it to structures; the normal lifetime-extension will not be performed, so structures will be pointing to destructed storage:


6 - The array has the same lifetime as any other temporary object (12.2), except that initializing an initializer_list object from the array extends the lifetime of the array exactly like binding a reference to a temporary [...]

Note that clang agrees with MSVC on this; gcc performs lifetime extension on the backing array, but it is erroneous to do so (Bug filed: https://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=66476).

If you want copy-initialization (with lifetime extension), use an equals sign:

std::initializer_list<TestStructure> structures = {structure};

Otherwise, use direct-list-initialization (using braces directly):

std::initializer_list<TestStructure> structures{structure};


How to get previous version using git and VS Express for web 2013?

I want to find the cause of a bug which caused by one of the recent commits. Is it possible to get a specific version, and then undo the checkouts?

OData Endpoint with .NET

I am trying to create an odata endpoint for a table valued function in a database. I am sure with the code, however upon running the application i get the error Server Error in '/' Application. Parser Error Description: An error occurred during the parsing of a resource required to...

Sorting vector of Pointers of Custom Class

I have vector<FPGA*> current_generation_, which I'd like to sort by FPGA member fitness_ using the sort_members function. Applicable code follows: bool sort_members (FPGA* fpga_first, FPGA* fpga_second) { return (fpga_first->fitness() < fpga_second->fitness()); }; fpga.hpp #include <vector> class FPGA { public: explicit FPGA(int input_gates, int output_gates, int normal_gates); const int fitness(); protected:...

How to match one of multiple alternative patterns with C++11 regex [duplicate]

This question already has an answer here: Strange results when using C++11 regexp with gcc 4.8.2 (but works with Boost regexp) [duplicate] 1 answer With Perl, the following results in a match: echo xyz | perl -ne 'print if (/.*(yes|no|xy).*/);' I'm trying to achieve the same thing with a...

C++ operator []

I am trying to implement the operator [] that is to be used once for Set and once as Get, i need to differentiate between the two cases, as in the case of get, i need to throw an exception if the returned value is equal to -1; whereas in...

Should checking loop conditions be counted towards total number of comparisons?

I have implemented three different sorting algorithms and now I want to confirm that my approach of counting the total number of comparisons is correct. In my mind, the number of comparisons shouldn't be tied to the conditional branches because if the condition isn't met, the comparison was still made...

C++11 Allocation Requirement on Strings

I had heard that C++11 was going to require strings to be allocated in contiguous memory. I even thought I saw a stack overflow question on it, but I can't seem to find it. I know that in practice both gcc and Visual Studio do allocate strings contiguously, I'm just...

Passing something as this argument discards qualifiers

Using the below code, i get the following compile error: In static member function ‘static std::string ctedata::Record::getDispatcher<std::basic_string<char> >::impl(const ctedata::Record&, const string&)’: /home/jason/CrownTheEmpire/lib/ctedata/data.h:111:38: error: passing ‘const std::map<std::basic_string<char>, std::basic_string<char> >’ as ‘this’ argument discards qualifiers [-fpermissive] return rec.fieldValues_[field]; ^ In file included from /usr/include/c++/5.1.0/map:61:0, from...

How can I simulate a nested function without lambda expressions in C++11?

I have the following code: int main(int argc, char **argv) { App app(800, 600); app.add_event_scene(Scene("Event Plot", event_plot)); Image x("sample.png"); struct foo { static void visual_plot() { x.draw(); } }; // Error. app.add_visual_scene(Scene("Visual Plot", foo::visual_plot)); app.run(); return 0; } And I get the following error: ||=== Build: Debug in Joy-Plus-Plus (compiler:...

Call template function for the value of a pointer out of a template function, in C++

I am trying to call a template function for the pointer that was given as template parameter in my calling function. My code is: template <> struct serialize_helper<std::string> { // not important code... } }; template <class T> inline void serializer(const T& obj, StreamType::iterator& res) { if(std::is_pointer<T>::value) { //THIS doesn'...

Type function that returns a tuple of chosen types

I've implemented a type function Tuple that turn a list of My_enum values into an std::tuple of corresponding types: #include <tuple> enum My_enum{ t_int, t_double }; // Bind_type is a type function that given a My_enum returns the corresponding type template<My_enum E> struct Bind_type; template<> struct Bind_type<t_int>{ using type =...

Using Try/Catch block to set file path?

I'm having a bit of trouble figuring out an assignment for my Visual Basic course. I am told to assume that a given text file is not in the \bin\Debug folder of my program, so I am trying to throw an exception error and get the correct path from the...

Visual Studio Assembly force-installs Target Framework

I have this Assembly targeted at .NET 3.5. The code will work on later versions as well, but I like this to work on Windows XP. I mean, .NET is backwards compatible, right? I can run apps for .NET 3.5 on Windows 8.1. However, when I run my own assembly,...

std::move on a C++ class does not move all members?

I understand that using v.push_back(std::move(foo)) will move foo contents to a vector. However I do not understand why the below code : #include <iostream> #include <vector> struct Foo { std::string s; float f; friend std::ostream& operator<<(std::ostream& stream,const Foo& foo) { stream << "{" << foo.s << ":" << foo.f <<...

devenv.exe hogs CPU when debugging

Short version: When I debug ASP.NET MVC apps in VS2013 and try to edit razor views or css files, the CPU usage of devenv.exe skyrockets to the point where VS becomes unresponsive. Browser link is turned off, yet this still happens. Restarting debugging doesn't help, restarting VS doesn't help, restarting...

Visual Studio 2013 LINK : fatal error LNK1181: cannot open input file

I am using Visual Studio 2013. I'm trying to build some code given to me from my professor and I keep getting this error: LINK : fatal error LNK1181: cannot open input file 'C:\Users\manduchi\Documents\eyegaze\EyeGazeDemo..\Libraries\OpenCV\lib\opencv_core249.lib' However, on my computer opencv_core249.lib is located somewhere else. I've tried updating the linker directories to...

HTTP Error 403.14

I'm developing my MVC 5 app using VS 2013, it was working fine, but suddenly it's giving the following error. HTTP Error 403.14 - Forbidden The Web server is configured to not list the contents of this directory. I've already read this post, and it didn't solve the problem. I've...

Dereferencing a temporary unique_ptr

unique_ptr<A> myFun() { unique_ptr<A> pa(new A()); return pa; } const A& rA = *myFun(); This code compiles but rA contains garbage. Can someone explain to me why is this code invalid? Note: if I assign the return of myFun to a named unique_ptr variable before dereferencing it, it works fine....

Visual Studio 2013 Report RDLC with related datasets

I currently have two tables in a database "customer" and "pricelist" where a customer can have multiple pricelist items linked to their ID. I'm trying to build a report in VS2013 where it lists all customers [alphabetically], then all of their pricelist items [alphabetically], then page break between each customer....

How can I convert an int to a string in C++11 without using to_string or stoi?

I know it sounds stupid, but I'm using MinGW32 on Windows7, and "to_string was not declared in this scope." It's an actual GCC Bug, and I've followed these instructions and they did not work. So, how can I convert an int to a string in C++11 without using to_string or...

Implicit use of initializer_list

§[dcl.init.list] 8.5.4/2: The template std::initializer_list is not predefined; if the header <initializer_list> is not included prior to a use of std::initializer_list — even an implicit use in which the type is not named ( — the program is ill-formed. Does that mean this program is ill-formed? #include <vector> int main()...

In c++11 what should happen first: raw string expansion or macros?

This code works in visual c++ 2013 but not in gcc/clang: #if 0 R"foo( #else int dostuff () { return 23; } // )foo"; #endif dostuff(); Visual C++ removes the if 0 first. Clang expands the R raw string first (and never defining dostuff). Who is right and why?...

Same function with and without template

I am trying to understand a piece of code of C++11. A class contains 2 functions as shown below: class abc { public: void integerA(int x); template<typename typ> void integerA(typ x); }; I am unable to understand benefit of declaring 2 same functions. Why not declare only one template function?...

Visual Studios building and debugging .cpp file without main()

Professor just gave us a block of c++ code in order to learn about the debug windows in Visual Studio, however after creating a blank win32 console project and then dragging in the .cpp file I get the missing .exe error message when attempting to debug. I've looked everywhere and...

syntax for calling a method on a member with multiple instances

I the following case template<typename T> class base{ public: void test(){} }; template<typename T> class helper{ public: base<T> t; }; template<typename T, typename ... Ts> class holder: public helper<T>, helper<Ts>... { }; int main(int argc, char *argv[]){ holder<int, short, long> h; h.t.test(); // of course, error here } Which compiles...

Atomic/not-atomic mix, any guarantees?

Let's I have GUI thread with code like this: std::vector<int> vec; std::atomic<bool> data_ready{false}; std::thread th([&data_ready, &vec]() { //we get data vec.push_back(something); data_ready = true; }); draw_progress_dialog(); while (!data_ready) { process_not_user_events(); sleep_a_little(); } //is it here safe to use vec? As you see I not protect "vec" by any kind of...

Junk varchar entries in MSSQL database using ODBC

I'm trying to insert a string-variable into a varchar(100)-field, but if the string is longer than 15 elements only junk is inserted (e.g. "0‰?"). First my setup: Development: Win7 (64bit) / VS2013 / C++11 / 64bit Application Database: Win8 (64bit) / Microsoft SQL Server Express 2014 (64bit) Driver: SQL Server...

Why is the boolean value within a structure within a vector not being updated?

This might sound like a very basic question, but I have trying to fix a simple bug for over an hour now and I can't seem to understand what's happening. I have the following structure declaration in my header file: struct StudentBody { string name; Vec2 position; bool disabled; StudentBody(string...

Why is initialization of enum class temporaries with arbitrary values allowed?

I came across some code like the following in one the CppCon 2014 talks that confused the heck out of me. The audience accepted it without comment, so I presume that it's legal: enum class Foo { Bar }; Foo const v1 = Foo(5); The question is: why does this...

Call to implicitly-deleted copy constructor in LLVM(Porting code from windows to mac)

We are in the process of porting some c++ code from windows to mac and are having issues compiling it with LLVM 6.1 using c++11. We are encountering errors all over the place of "Call to implicitly-deleted copy contructor" Some of these errors are popping up in our code. for...

Simple thread/mutex test application is crashing

I wrote a simple test program which accumulates random samples to a buffer using multiple threads. Each thread uses a stack for reducing the mutex waits. This is for investigating problems in a much larger program. The code currently crashes on mingw-w64 4.9.2 Any idea why? Debugging halts on "signal-received"...

Searching user tasks by task.body text

Good morning all! I have spent a good bit of time searching and reading forums about this, but I can't seem to find a solution. Any help you all can offer is greatly appreciated. I have created an Outlook Add-In via C# and Visual Studio 2013. This add-in will create...

IIS Express 8 - Max allowed length

In case the below is too long, my question is whether IIS Express 8 in Visual Studio 2013 obeys the maxAllowedContentLength attribute or if it has some overriding value that prevents large requests When debugging some webapi calls against Visual Studio 2013, I'm receiving this error: Maximum request length exceeded....

C++ why does SFINAE fail with only a class template parameter?

I'm using SFINAE in the style of this answer in order to call a generic vector object by using an appropriate member function. For example, the following code calls operator[](int) const first, and if that doesn't exist then operator()(int) const: template<int I> struct rank : rank<I-1> { static_assert(I > 0,...

How do I install the Wix extension on after a Visual Studio 2013 Update?

I have installed Wix 3.9 on VS 2012. Recently, I just got VS 2013 and I am not sure how to install just the extension on there? How do I do without uninstalling wix 3.9 and reinstalling it back again?...

How to create a folder that contains the current date and time instead of name

I use C++ Windows Form application in Visual Studio 2013 for one project. I wonder how to create a folder that contains the current date and time instead of name? It is possible to make such folder?? DirectoryInfo^ directory = Directory::CreateDirectory("C:\Users\Desktop\" + ??); ...

I think assigning JsonValue values to JsonValues might be very slow, in comparison to having a Value be a key

Json::Value is located in: #include <json/value.h> I have a result Json::Value object being created which will be pushed back to the user. The issue with it is that it takes a super long time to complete, which boggles my mind. I think that there is something off with Json::Value, maybe...

Is executing C++ code in comments with certain Unicode characters allowed, like in Java?

I know that executing Java code in comments with certain Unicode characters is allowed. Please see this question for further clarification Executing Java code in comments. So was just curious to know if C++ has such features?

How can I add a .props file to a C# project?

I am trying to set up continuous delivery of Azure Web Jobs, and came across this post from the Azure blog. One of the steps there is to add a .props file to the web job application's properties. I am having difficulty adding a .props file. My web searches indicate...

Visual Studio Ctrl + F search freezes when including a '(' character

For some reason whenever I include the '(' character in a Ctrl + F search in Visual Studio 2013 the search bar never works. It doesn't matter what other text is included in the search bar. It doesn't matter if I choose to search on just the current document, or...

VS2013 Error: LNK2019 When trying to build ZeroMQ server

I'm trying to build this simple ZeroMQ server in C++ on Visual Studio 2013. #include "stdafx.h" #include "zmq.hpp" #include <string> #include <iostream> #include <windows.h> using namespace std; int _tmain(int argc, _TCHAR* argv[]) { // Prepare context and socket zmq::context_t ctx(1); zmq::socket_t sckt(ctx, ZMQ_REP); sckt.bind("tcp://*:5555"); while (true) { zmq::message_t request; //...

The name 'Thread' does not exist in the current context

When I put this code Thread.Sleep(2000); it gives me the error: The name 'Thread' does not exist in the current context`. I already included the namespace using System.Threading;. See System.Threading.Thread.Sleep() on MSDN....

How to re-write templated function to handle type deduction

So, I have this search function for the map container: template <typename Key, typename T> void searchInMapByKey(std::map<Key,T> Map, T keyValue) { if(Map.empty()) { std::cout << "Map is empty, nothing to search for..." << "\n"; } else { for(const auto & element : Map) { if(element.first==keyValue) { std::cout << keyValue <<...

Can't compile C++11 source using GCC 5.1 toolchain

I'm trying to compile a library written with C++11 features using GCC 5.1 on Ubuntu. However, it complains std::unique_ptr is not defined. gcc (Ubuntu 5.1.0-0ubuntu11~14.04.1) 5.1.0 g++ (Ubuntu 5.1.0-0ubuntu11~14.04.1) 5.1.0 CXX flags: -std=c++11 -Wall -Wextra -Weffc++ -pedantic Output: error: ‘unique_ptr’ in namespace ‘std’ does not name a template type std::unique_ptr<...

How to use ajax to post json string to controller method?

I want to be able to post a json string to a control action but it's always receive the string as null. If I create a view model for the controller method, it works, but that's not what I want since there will be too much view models to maintain....

Mapping const char * to duck-typed T at compile-time or run-time

I have many classes A, B, C, D, etc that are duck-typed and thus have the same methods and interface but do not inherit from the same class. E.g. class A { public: void foo(); void bar(); } class B { public: void foo(); void bar(); } class C {...

C++ error: deduced conflicting types for parameter 'T' string vs const char *

So, I am writing a simple, templated search function for deque container. Here's the code: template <typename T> void searchInDequeFor(std::deque<T> Deque, T searchValue) { for(const auto & element : Deque) { if(Deque.empty()) { std::cout << "Deque is empty, nothing to search for..." << "\n"; } else if(element==searchValue) { std::cout <<...

No match for 'operator*' error

Hello fellow programmers! I was going to write a small program for calculating total pay for different periods of time depending on the amount of hours and the salary that the user enters. I managed to make a small bit of the program but when I try to run it...

Calling variadic template function with no args failing

Given the following code: #include <iostream> template <typename... Args> void foo(Args&&... bargs, Args&&... aargs) { std::cout << "Hello" << std::endl; } int main() { foo<int, double>(1, 2.0, 3, 4.0); //OK foo<char>('c', 'd'); // OK foo(); //FAIL } I get the following compiler error: In function 'int main()': 15:9: error: no...

“Emulating” std::declval issues. Works (kind of) in g++, fails to compile in clang++

Trying to better understand std::declval, I came up with the following "toy model" code: #include <iostream> #include <typeinfo> struct Bar { Bar(double); // some non-default ctor double f(); // some function of which return type we want to get }; using Barref = Bar&&; // emulating std::declval<Bar>() int main() {...