ruby,precision,equality,bigdecimal , Comparing two virtually identical BigDecimal numbers in Ruby on Rails

## Question:

Tag: ruby,precision,equality,bigdecimal

I got a little problem that I really would like to understand. I am using assert_equal to compare two BigDecimal numbers that are supposed to be identical. They actually are except a very little tiny fraction, see below:

-#<BigDecimal:7f4b40e8de78,'0.4021666666 6666666666 666666667E2',36(45)>
+#<BigDecimal:7f4b40e85db8,'0.4021666666 6666666666 6666668E2',36(63)>


I use assert_in_delta in order to not fail the test cases. So I got a reasonable workaround. I do wonder though whether it would be possible to have it equal:

assert_equal (241.30.to_d/6), model.division_function


The model's division_function does exactly the same. It divides a BigDecimal of value 241.3 by the length of an array, which is 6.

There seems to be a very tiny difference in the precision. I would like to know where that might come from? Is there a way I can control precision more accurately?

EDIT I am using Mongoid. It is worth to note that Mongoid offers BigDecimal as a field type, but it is stored as a string. However, I don't think this is the problem. I believe it is a Ruby thing.

EDIT I got a little further with an example which hints that it is a Ruby issue and not directly related to Rails. Please see below:

irb(main):041:0* amount1 = BigDecimal("241.3")
=> #<BigDecimal:7f49bcb03558,'0.2413E3',18(18)>
irb(main):042:0> amount2 = BigDecimal("1800")
=> #<BigDecimal:7f49bcaf3400,'0.18E4',9(18)>
irb(main):043:0> rate = amount1 / amount2
=> #<BigDecimal:7f49bcae8398,'0.1340555555 5555555555 5555556E0',27(45)>
irb(main):044:0> rate * amount2 #should return amount1 = 241.3, but it does not :-(
irb(main):045:0>


I reported the bug to the Ruby core team. However, this is not a bug as you can see in the rejection response.

BigDecimal, though offers arbitrary precision, cannot represent numbers like 1/3 precisely. Thus during some arithmetic you can encounter imprecisions.

You can use Rational in Ruby for exact numbers. Exercise caution when doing arithmetics if you wish to keep the result exact.

# Related:

## For loop with flexible stop variable

ruby
I need to write a loop for x in (1..y) where the y variable can be changed somehow. How can I do that? For example: for x in (1..y/x) But it does not work. ...

## Rails - link_to path based on object's name + refactoring multiple custom actions

ruby-on-rails,ruby,refactoring
I'm looking to simplify the link_to path based on thr object's name and also am looking into refactoring multiple custom actions. I've managed to get this working below. <% ServiceMenu.all.each do |menu| %> <tr class=" <%= cycle('odd', 'even') %>"> <td><%= link_to menu.name, ("tech/""#{menu.name.parameterize}") %></td> </tr> <% end %> I feel...

## How to handle backslash “\” escape characters in q string and heredocument

ruby
Ruby Newbie here. I do not understand why Ruby looks inside %q and escapes the \. I am using Ruby to generate Latex code. I need to generate \\\hline which is used in Latex for table making. I found \\\hline as input generated \hline even though the string was inside...

## On rendering from controller, current_page method does not seem to work

ruby-on-rails,ruby,ruby-on-rails-4,model-view-controller
I have a navigation bar included in application.html.erb. Because for some pages, such as the signup page, I need to place additional code inside the navigation bar, I have excluded those pages for showing the navigation bar through application.html.erb and instead included it in their respective view pages. See code...

## Heroku rake db:migrate failing - uninitialized constant

ruby-on-rails,ruby,heroku
My app is working fine locally and my push to Heroku was successful. But, when I run heroku run rake db:migrate, I get the following error: NameError: uninitialized constant AddWeightToExercises Here is the failed migration: class AddWeightToExercise < ActiveRecord::Migration def change add_column :exercises, :weight, :float end end edit: Thanks for...

## Split an array into slices, with groupings

arrays,ruby,enumerable
I've got some Ruby code here, that works, but I'm certain I'm not doing it as efficiently as I can. I have an Array of Objects, along this line: [ { name: "foo1", location: "new york" }, { name: "foo2", location: "new york" }, { name: "foo3", location: "new york"...

## Same enum values for multiple columns

ruby-on-rails,ruby,enums
I need to do something like this: class PlanetEdge < ActiveRecord::Base enum :first_planet [ :earth, :mars, :jupiter] enum :second_planet [ :earth, :mars, :jupiter] end Where my table is a table of edges but each vertex is an integer. However, it seems the abvove is not possible in rails. What might...

## Map with accumulator on an array

ruby,inject
I'm looking to create a method for Enumerable that does map and inject at the same time. For example, calling it map_with_accumulator, [1,2,3,4].map_with_accumulator(:+) # => [1, 3, 6, 10] or for strings ['a','b','c','d'].map_with_accumulator {|acc,el| acc + '_' + el} # => ['a','a_b','a_b_c','a_b_c_d'] I fail to get a solution working. I...

ruby

## Heroku RAM not increasing with upgraded dynos

ruby-on-rails,ruby,ruby-on-rails-3,memory,heroku
I have a massive function i have been calling manually through the heroku rails console. I have been receiving the error rapid fire in my logs: 2015-06-22T14:56:42.940517+00:00 heroku[run.9877]: Process running mem=575M(112.4%) 2015-06-22T14:56:42.940517+00:00 heroku[run.9877]: Error R14 (Memory quota exceeded) A 1X dyno is suppose to have 512 MB of RAM. I...

## RSpec test for rake task

I have created a custom rake task that deletes all items that are >= 7 days old. I am trying to write a RSpec test for this new task but it seems like my task isn't really running in the test. I have tested the task manually and it works...

## Undefined local variable post

ruby-on-rails,ruby,variables,undefined,local
I write this code: <% @user.posts.each do |post| %> <%= render 'post', locals: { post: post, user: @user} %> <% end %> Then in _post.htm.erb I write follow code: <div class="post-title"> <img src="<%= @user.avatar.url%>" class="img-rounded post-image"> <h4 id="post-name"><%= @user.first_name + ' ' [email protected]_name %> </h4> <div id="post-date"><%= post.created_at.strftime('%d %b -...

## How could I padding spaces to a fix length

ruby
I need all strings' length with 5 Original [477, 4770,] Expected ["477 ", "4770 "] How could I do it with Ruby ?...

## String#scan not capturing all occurences

ruby,regex
I'm facing a very strange behaviour with ruby String#scan method return. I have this code below and I can't find out why "scan" doesn't return 2 elements. str = "10011011001" regexp = "0110" p str.scan(/(#{regexp})/) ==> [["0110"]] String "str" clearly contains 2 occurences of pattern "0110". I want to fetch...

## How to flatten a structure of embedded Set and Hash

ruby,recursion
I would like to convert an embedding structure into a flat one. An embedding structure is a set of 0 or more objects, such as: a string or a hash having some string as key and some other embedding structure as value. A flat structure is a set of arrays...

## Can't map a range of dates in Ruby/Rails

ruby-on-rails,ruby
I'm trying to map a range of dates and pass them to my view as an array, as follows: from, to = Date.parse("2014-01-01"), Date.yesterday date_range = (from..to) @mapped_dates = date_range.map {|date| date.strftime("%b %e")} I reference them in some JS in my view as follows: dateLabels = <%= raw @mapped_dates.to_json %>;...

## Call method to generate arguments in ruby works in 1.8.7 but not 1.9.3

ruby-on-rails,ruby,ruby-1.9.3
This is something that I had working in ruby 1.8.7, but no longer works in 1.9.3, and I am not sure what changes make this fail. Previously, I had something like this myFunction(submitArgs()) where submitArgs was a helper method that could be called with some options def submitArgs(args={}) #Some logic/manipulations...

## In Ruby how to put multiple lines in one guard clause?

ruby-on-rails,ruby
I have the following line of code : if params[:"available_#{district.id}"] == 'true' @deliverycharge = @product.deliverycharges.create!(districtrate_id: district.id) delivery_custom_price(district) end Rubocop highlight it and asks me to use a guard clause for it. How can I do it? EDIT : Rubocop highlighted the first line and gave this message Use a guard...